What does it mean when a valuation gives a range instead of a number?

A range is not the agent hedging. It reports how much the comparable sales disagreed with each other once they had been adjusted, which is a fact about the evidence rather than a statement about the person delivering it. A single figure is not more precise. It has simply left the disagreement out.

Most sellers read it the other way. A range looks like someone who has not finished the work, or who is leaving themselves room to ask for a reduction later. So the range gets collapsed into one number, and a confidence the sales never supported gets asserted on their behalf.

Where the width comes from

Start with six comparable sales. Each is adjusted toward your house: for size, for an extra bathroom, for condition, for age, for whatever else separates it from yours. That produces six adjusted figures.

If those six land within a few thousand dollars of each other, the evidence is dense and pointing in one direction, and a narrow range is the honest output. If they scatter across eighty thousand dollars, the evidence is thin or the property is unusual, and a narrow range would be an invention.

So the width is derived rather than chosen. It comes from what the adjusted sales did. That is what makes it a finding.

The range should have a reason attached

A range given without explanation is where most of the damage happens. The seller is handed two numbers and no account of what produced them, so they fall back on the interpretation they already had, which is that the agent is covering themselves.

One sentence fixes it. This range is eighteen thousand wide because five of the six sales agreed closely and one sold in circumstances I have accounted for but cannot fully verify. That does three things at once. It states the finding, it shows the sales were examined individually rather than averaged, and it makes the range checkable.

What the two ends are for

The lower end is what the property should clear at inside the normal selling window on current evidence. The upper end is what becomes reachable if presentation, timing and condition all work in its favour.

Those are not error bars around a true price. They are two outcomes with different requirements attached, and knowing which requirements apply to which end is the actual planning conversation.

When a narrow range is the right answer

None of this argues that wide is honest and narrow is not. In a subdivision of repeated floor plans with six recent sales of the same plan, the adjusted values will cluster and the supported range really is narrow. Widening it to appear careful is the same failure pointed the other way.

The discipline is that the width is reported rather than decided. A tight range on a tract home and a wide one on a custom build are both correct outputs of the same process, which is what makes either of them defensible when questioned. Where two valuations of the same house land apart, the reasons are set out in why two valuations of the same house disagree.

Frequently asked questions

Why did I get a price range instead of a price?

Because the comparable sales did not agree once they were adjusted. A range reports how much they disagreed. Six adjusted sales that land within a few thousand dollars of each other support a narrow range. Six that scatter across eighty thousand do not, and a single figure drawn from them would be asserting a precision the evidence cannot carry.

Is a wide valuation range bad?

Not by itself. A wide range on an unusual property with few true peers is the accurate answer, and narrowing it would be a fabrication. What should prompt a question is a range presented with no explanation of what made it that wide, because then there is no finding attached to it and you cannot tell the difference between thin evidence and a careless analysis.

What makes a home valuation more accurate?

More truly comparable sales, closer in time, with known condition. Accuracy comes from the quality of the evidence rather than from how the answer is presented. A valuation that shows which sales it used, which it excluded and why, and what the width of its range is reporting, gives you something you can test. That is worth more than a number carried to the dollar.

One limit, stated plainly: a narrow range built on six near-identical sales with thin condition records is confident and not necessarily correct. Width reports agreement among the sales that were used. It cannot report what those records left out.

---

This article is general information, not financial advice. For a specific home, have a local agent run a comparative market analysis on current comparable sales.

The Independent Agent
Substack | Spotify | CMAflow FAQ | YouTube | Free CMA | Home valuation | Blog | Desk